Saturday, October 17, 2009

And now, a rare opinion piece

Generally, I keep my online interactions as free of conflict as I can manage, with the result that I don't often take strong positions publicly anymore. Generally, I prefer to try to see things from the perspective of those articulate people I read whose opinions differ from mine in order to learn more about them, more about the subject, and more about myself. Generally, I choose to remain silent rather than stir the pot where integrity allows it.

Generally, rules have exceptions, and today is the exception.

For whatever reason(s), I have within the past week been exposed to varying degrees of disrespect for my choice to have become a mother, in person and online. And let me state very clearly that I did CHOOSE to become a mother. 3 times. I have given birth to 3 children and am doing my level best to raise them into people I like hanging out with.

That said, I have absolutely no interest in whether anyone else on this planet chooses to do so. I have friends of all stripes, ages, preferences and opinions and I like to believe that I am able to respect our differences as well as our common humanity. Your choice NOT to become a parent does not in any negative way color my opinion of you. In fact, if anything, being in the parenting trenches myself, I completely respect people who acknowledge that they do not wish to take on that responsibility. Because people who have children and then abdicate that responsibility piss me off like very few other things, one of them being people who take on a pet and then abdicate that responsibility. That behavior gives me RAGE.

To be clear, then: I have nothing but respect (and occasional envy) of people who remain childless by choice. I expect nothing but respect in return.

AND I'LL NOW TELL YOU WHY: Do you expect to have doctors, golf courses, banks, grocery stores, airline pilots, waiters, baristas, scientists, government services, hotels and other such niceties when you are old and retired? I'll bet you do. And on whose backs do you think those duties will fall? MY CHILDREN and their generation, thankyouverymuch. If I and other "breeders" didn't create and contribute them to your future society, you could have a pretty miserable old age.

In closing then, do what you want. I'm cool with it. You should be too. But don't you DARE give me shit about having done what I want. Especially since you will one day benefit from it.

22 Comments:

At 8:34 AM, Blogger Heather Anne Hogan said...

I have given birth to 3 children and am doing my level best to raise them into people I like hanging out with.

What a great philosophy on raising kids!

You're great, Shari. Sorry peoples are giving you grief. :)

 
At 8:36 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

Whew girl, don't hold back now! :) I cannot stand the term "breeders" or the term "child-free". I have no problem with people who choose not to have kids, but there is no need to announce it to the world and demand certain things because of it.

 
At 8:38 AM, Blogger Brandon said...

i turned on the news and saw a report of a mama bear on the rampage and the link led here.

sorry folks have got you down. if i have one complaint about your choice to become a parent, it's that you do it so well.

 
At 8:40 AM, Blogger Jennie said...

Breeder is such a gross word. I'm glad you had kids. From what you've written about them, they seem brilliant and unique and fun, most likely because they have you as a mother.

I think it might have been a-hole week on the internets. I hope it's over now.

 
At 8:43 AM, Blogger kat said...

DOUBLE don't give you shit for raising three of the most kick-ass children in the whole entire world!

The internets are assholes, Shari. And no matter how assholey they're being to you, i hope you know that you're my very favorite.

 
At 9:16 AM, Blogger matt said...

Maybe the only saving grace is that said fools don't have children of their own to pass such dumbass views on... you're awesome, Shari, and such fools are a good reason to bring back a little more natural selection.

 
At 9:29 AM, Blogger eclectic said...

H!A!: Thanks. You're great, too, y'know.

M&M: So... it was too subtle? ;)

/B\: ***ROAR***

Thanks, man. Of course, having never met my kids, you could be approving the fine band of hellions I'm raising... but I appreciate your faith in me.

Jennie: You're right! It WAS asshole week! I think it has to be over now, because we call this the week-END. Whew.

Kat: :) I love that you are in my corner. Thank you!

If it were just the internets, I think I might have let it go. But someone had the audacity in person to ask my son -- in my presence -- if he had plans to be a 'breeder' when he grows up, in response to his statement that as a family, we try to be environmentally responsible. Grrrrr.

Matt: Oooh, the first reference to Darwin! I KNOW, right? And thanks.



EVERYONE: I love you guys! Thanks for stopping by to remind me that I really do like people afterall.

 
At 10:47 AM, Blogger Ashley said...

I really, really don't understand people who insist on referring to people having children as "breeders." It implies both that people who choose to do so are nothing but animals, and that "non-breeders" are worth more than "breeders." I mean, what is the logic behind this? Are they advocating that the human race should die out? That we should starting splitting in half like amoebas? I mean, what?

 
At 11:15 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

There could NEVER be enough mini-Shari kids in the world:)

Hell, I wish we could send ALL kids to your house for life training because the world would be a much more kind & civil place.

I've met your kids and they are great people. Try not to let this get to you. Sounds like it was a very stupid comment from someone who wasn't using their head.

 
At 12:46 PM, Blogger Kentucky Brat said...

and what did you say to this 'in person' person? Me thinking about someone saying that to my kid (years ago of course) flips switches in my brain that should not be flipped.

I had a boss once... oh my! All I could think of was how I was going to hide his body!

 
At 1:49 PM, Blogger traci said...

It's interesting that you would post this today. This week, my favorite radio station had quite a debate about this exact thing. I'm with you, Twinnie. I don't give a rat's ass about what other people choose but for gawd's sake, give me the same courtesy I give you! I LOVE YOU! You just keep on rockin' the mom thing and I'll trip all those twits giving you a hard time!

 
At 2:19 PM, Blogger mama biscuit said...

I have to be honest, I had never heard the term "breeder" in reference to people who have children until this week. I find it highly offensive. I can't believe someone spoke to your son like that. What an inappropriate and rude comment to make to a child.

I respect people who know they are not meant to be parents and thank them for being smart enough to follow their instincts!

 
At 7:37 AM, Blogger Susie said...

I am stunned that anyone would say such things to or about you. Truly stunned. Whenever I meet absolutely lovely, first-rate humans, I find myself hoping that they will raise children. To improve the overall quality of the species -- in terms of kindness, goodness, reason. Some of those lovely people I know are raising children (like you), and some are not, for various reasons. As has been suggested here, people who would disrespect you in the ways you've described are those for whom remaining "child-free" is the only right choice. We just don't need any more of them, thankyouverymuch.

AND there is a posse at your disposal, should the need arise for some ass-kickin'. You know this.

 
At 6:12 AM, Blogger zuhn said...

I would totally join Susie's ass-kicking posse.

I hope you told these haters you are raising Super Kids because you are. And that even your littlest has already proven himself to be awesomer than whoever is angering the eclectic.

 
At 8:04 AM, Blogger eclectic said...

Asheley Awesome: I KNOW! What is WITH that?

Shangie: I love you guys. Thanks.

Kentucky Brat: I think I said, "Excuse me?" And then my son and I continued out of the area before I became one of "Those Crazy People" you see on the news.

Twinnie: Thank you! My own personal tripper!

TysGirl: Exactly. Follow those instincts, people.

Susie: Thanks you, my sister. That's my general thought as well.

Truthfully, the blogs and articles I read online were NOT directed at me personally, but because of their tone and language, it was impossible for me as a parent not to be offended.

The comment in person was supposedly directed at "enlightening" my son that if he wishes to be environmentally friendly, he should choose to refrain from having children. It was stated in a nasty way though, overtly implying that people who "breed" are per se irresponsible toward the planet.

Zuhn: Yay! My posse has piercings! We are SO badass! So, when you coming down south to meet my awesome kids? ;)

 
At 10:25 AM, Blogger WILLIAM said...

Wait a minute...there is a choice when it comes down to having kids? No one told me there was choice..what the?

 
At 3:55 PM, Blogger eclectic said...

Bill: Heh. Not for you, silly.

 
At 12:04 PM, Blogger Unknown said...

You have three of the most amazing little people I can ever remember meeting, which makes me wonder why the roving jackass lobby doesn't spend their time querying the legions of heinous parents that infest 'Mother Earth' and leave the ones who clearly excel alone.

 
At 6:08 PM, Blogger eclectic said...

Sir: Thank you, really. You stating so means very much to me.

I'm usually much better at letting stuff roll right off, but it was weird how the universe conspired to expose me to all of it in the span of less than a week. It overloaded my mama-bear sensor I guess. I really need to post something else and push this down the page a little now, I think.

 
At 11:35 AM, Blogger I'm not here. said...

Will try to comment again, Blogger was acting up a while back:

...whuh?

Someone went up to your son and asked him if he was going to be a breeder when he grows up?
Was that person drunk? Did they recently hit their head on a blunt object? What the fu-

*this comment has been stopped due to high frequencies of profanity that would make Louis Black sound like a Sunday School teacher*

 
At 8:44 PM, Blogger Iron Fist said...

Having basked in the awesomeness that is your entire family I can safely say that no doubt the entire WORLD will benefit from your having kids one day. And I'm not just saying that because you let me drink your good scotch, either.

 
At 10:43 AM, Blogger Poe Cooper said...

Hi, I found you via Scott's blog (Caveat Emptor).

For whatever it is worth, I think it is really, really weird that anyone would say anything to you about being a mother. Where I'm from (West Virginia and South Carolina), women are expected to become mothers. In fact, I am sometimes cornered and asked why I am NOT a mother, and reminded that my child bearing years are waning. It always hurts my feelings, because I want to be a mother.

As Woody Allen said in "Mighty Aphrodite", women are compelled to motherhood as rivers are compelled to the sea. Even if it is not true, I think it is sort of a beautiful thought.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home